For Earth By Us, AKA Febu Enzyme Oxygen Laundry Booster - An Example of Enzyme + Oxi Style Booster
The laundry aisle is almost as bad as the makeup department: alluringly-packaged products at varying prices, all promising whiteness and removal of unsightly blemishes and displays of fragrances of a purported delicate and alluring nature. It’s enough to leave anyone befuddled.
There’s a lot of discussion about the role of various laundry boosters. I stan Biz and Febu because, well, they're awesome, but there are lots of other products out there, and they differ in subtle and not-so-subtle ways. I’m going to wade in to loosely classifying products by what they contain and what they can do for your laundry. And at the bottom of the page, there's a comparison tool for the dozens of options available in North America.
Much Like Pornography, I Know It When I See It: What Counts As A Booster?
What qualifies products to be on this list is loosely:
Adjuncts to laundry detergent - not standalone products
Used in the wash water - not spray pretreaters
Generally suitable for whites and colors - no chlorine bleach
Offer multiple benefits - so no products that are just water softeners in isolation like borax, washing soda and sodium citrate.
So there’s like 72 products on the list as of this writing. It’s admittedly a loose definition - there’s a lot of different booster products with a lot of different purported benefits, but laying them out this way sort of lets you see what does what and what’s close enough to something else that you might not need to buy both. As always, if a product is available primarily in Canada, it's noted with a maple leaf emojum 🍁 in the Name field.
There are a lot of highly-competent, highly-complete laundry products out there that can hit everything your laundry needs in one product. And they’re mostly affordable: powdered laundry detergents. If you are using powders by Tide, the new formula Gain, 365 Unscented from Whole Foods or The Unscented Co pacs, this list probably isn’t for you, because your detergent probably has something from most of the classes of ingredients I’m going to talk about here. Pat yourself on the back, go admire your clean clothes and uncluttered laundry supply shelf, and relax. If you think you need more cleaning power, dose up your existing powder a smidgen to a tad. There’s maybe four products mentioned here that can do something better than what you’re already using. Really. Powder On Powder is not a cost-effective strategy because there's a lot of duplication of ingredients. The exception to this is DNase - you probably could stand a booster for that. Conversely. . .
Almost Every Load With Liquid Detergent Benefits From A Booster:
Liquid users, you may be the victim of marketing hype. No matter what the happy talk on the front label says, liquid laundry detergent does not have “Oxi Action”. You can’t put oxidizers in a complete liquid laundry detergent or the jugs would burst before they left the factory and all of the enzymes would be cooked before the end of the factory shift. These manufacturer claims are based on things like optical brighteners (brightens without oxygen bleach!) or enzymes or chelators or special surfactants or whatever - but they aren’t oxygen bleach. Oxygen bleaching actives make a definite difference in certain stain removal and in malodor control. They also whiten and brighten rather than tricking you into thinking something is white and bright with physics and chemistry. So odds are, if you’re a liquid detergent user, unless you are exceptionally clean and tidy and only wear black clothing that never gets sweaty, you could get better results with something on this list.
The ingredients in boosters can be grouped in some functional classes, which helps make sense of what they can do for your laundry. The table groups ingredients thusly:
The specific ingredient in each of these classes doesn’t really matter (with the exception of enzymes) - you can get whitening effects with powder or liquid, you can solve odor problems in a number of ways - the idea is to be able to compare what kinds of ingredients a product contains to understand where it fits versus your particular laundry needs.
Let’s dive into each of the categories with some examples of what specific things each column can address:
Bleaching / Cleaning / Water Softening: agents that directly oxidize stains and odors, remove soils and condition water.
Oxygen Bleach: this is some source of hydrogen peroxide - either a solid adduct like sodium percarbonate or perborate where adding water of sufficient temperature breaks off the peroxide from a solid carrier, or actual liquid hydrogen peroxide without a carrier. Hydrogen peroxide is an oxidizer - it chemically modifies certain kinds of stains to turn them clear again, and it can rip up certain kinds of odor molecules, especially biological ones. What peroxide can’t do is actually remove particulate soils like dirt, dust and clay, nor does it do jack for fats and oils, like butter, skin oil or automotive lubricants. It also has a limited sanitizing and disinfecting action - but it’s important to note that in the US and Canada, none of these products are rated to kill any microorganism.
TAED: TAED is marketed as a bleach activator, which is a bit of a misnomer. It doesn’t break more peroxide off the adduct molecule - rather, it makes the most of the peroxide that has broken off by transforming it into a peroxy acid, which is a more effective cleaning, disinfecting and deodorizing agent. TAED is a double-edged sword - if a product has TAED, it’s generally best practice to make sure the product is **COMPLETELY** dissolved before it contacts textiles - so don’t use products with TAED as a paste on colored fabrics.
Surfactant: these are sudsy cleaning molecules that can attach soil to water so it can float away. Some surfactants are primarily attracted to soils without an electrical charge (non-ionic surfactants) and these help most with greasy soils. Others are anionic surfactants, and they work best on soils with a positive electrical charge, such as dirt, dust, clay and soot. Most booster products, unless they’re minimalist or pure peroxide liquids tend to have some surfactant in them, and it’s usually nonionic.
Water Softeners: these are agents that attempt to deal with calcium and magnesium in the wash water. They can either be “precipitating”, like sodium carbonate, which makes calcium form calcium carbonate micro crystals and fall out of solution, or “sequestering” like citrate and EDTA, which just keeps the calcium in solution but unable to interfere with other cleaning agents. For users with hard water, these water softeners can make a positive contribution to wash performance, or if the water is really hard and the softener is precipitating, cause texture and appearance issues, while being hard to rinse. I’ll dive deeper into this in a specific water-softening post.
Scent / Odor Control: perfumes and odor-specific active ingredients to break up, capture, neutralize or mask odor.
Fragrance is intensely personal, and if the product is fragrance-free or there is an otherwise-identical fragrance-free version to the fragranced brand-mate, I’ve indicated so here. Otherwise, assume all products are fragranced. With OxiClean products in particular, it is not safe to assume that things that sound very similar are identical otherwise if one is marked fragrance-free. There are a few products on the list that are “unscented”, but they appear to contain a masking fragrance, so sensitive users should read labels and ingredient disclosures carefully.
Zinc compounds have a long history of use in binding to sulfurous odors to make them too heavy to waft into the nose, and then allow them to be washed away. Products with zinc can be fragranced or unfragranced, but are typically perfumed as sulfurous organic molecules are just one cause of malodor. These can be particularly useful on garbage-y and damp odors.
Dextrins are corn- or tapioca-derived mechanical sponges that can grab odors to make them too heavy to waft to the nose, as well as make them easier to wash or rinse away, Febreze fabric sprays were the original application of this technology but it can work well in wash products too. They’re particularly good with pet and humanity odors.
Secret Sauce odor ingredients are usually either an antioxidant or an aromachemical believed to be nontoxic at the level in the product that doesn’t have to be disclosed under US or Canadian law as they are trade secrets. These are often sort of “pleasant” smelling products on their own, like cinnamates and terpenes, but since they’re not there just to smell good, can be classified as something other than perfume. Be skeptical of claims around these products, as there’s no one magic molecule that is perfectly safe and effective against all kinds of odor.
Enzymes: biocatalysts to target specific soil and odor issues. By breaking large organic molecules into smaller ones, removal by the detergent and water is substantially improved.
Protease: these are usually something like subtilisin or lichenase, and target protein soils like meat juices, blood, animal or human excretions, egg and sweat. Most laundry detergents that have any enzymes at all will already include an effective dose of a protease.
Amylase: this targets starchy stains like rice, potatoes, cornstarch, beans and oatmeal, and can remove some kinds of laundry starch from washing.
Lipase: our laundry’s best friend. Lipase targets oils from animal or vegetable sources including skin oils. It doesn’t do anything for oils of mineral origin like motor oil and vaseline.
Pectic Lyase: targets fruit, vegetable and plant stains by targeting the sticky sugar chains that hold these soils onto fabric
Mannanase: targets thickeners and emulsifiers found in things like coffee and chocolate, as well as additives in things like puddings, ice cream, yogurt, gravies, sauces and salad dressings.
Cellulase: rather than targeting stains, cellulases work by snipping off damaged cellulosic fibers like cotton, linen and ramie, as well as semi-cellulosic fibers like rayon, viscose, modal, Tencel, Lyocell and “bamboo”. By removing these short fuzzy damaged fibers, fabrics can appear smoother and brighter and be less prone to grabbing dust, dirt and soot from the environment.
DNase: also known as nuclease or phosphodiesterase, this is an enzyme that removes the biological glues that hold soils from living things (animals, plants, bacteria) to fibers. This results in improvements in color, texture and odor. I have an extremely detailed breakdown of the DNAse options at Find Some DNase in the USA .
Non-Bleach Brighteners: agents that keep removed soils from settling back on textiles.and agents to make whites appear whiter and colors more with a trick of chemistry and physics.
Anti-Redep: these are polymers or gums that keep removed soils and fugitive dye in suspension in the wash water as they’re removed, preventing them from sinking back onto or sticking to the now-clean fibers.
OBA: Optical Brightening Agents are near-colorless molecules that absorb light at one wavelength (usually invisible to the human eye) and reradiate it down as a color we can see, usually a bluish white. The effect reduces yellowness perception on whites and makes colors “pop”, especially on brights. The downside of OBAs is that they can make some darks, especially aging cottons, look “washed out” or “faded” - they’re still just as dark, but the fuzz radiates a lot of energy with a small bit of OBA and the effect reads as “fading” despite the dye being perfectly intact.
The Makers Of Michelob Light Lied To Us: You Cannot, In Fact, Have It All
Some of the items in this list are incompatible with others - if they were in the same bottle or wash process, they’d just cancel each other out. For example, liquid peroxide products can’t have enzymes, and products with certain types of anti-redep can’t have cellulase. So you may find that there’s certain combos of ingredients that you either need to get from your detergent and a booster, or two boosters. The filters down below will tell you if you're asking for the sun the moon and the stars in one bottle in a way that could lead to the destruction of the universe.
By further grouping products by which functional classes they contain, I came up with a few general archetypes of products.
All-In-One - these are powder products with something from each class - Biz is the archetype in the US, Resolve / Vanish in Canada and Mexico are the local equivalent.
Enzyme - these are enzyme products, without bleaching agents - Biz Liquid, Gear Guard/Gear Guard Advanced and Febreze In-Wash are examples.
Minimalist Oxi - these are Low-Ingredient Formulae targeting specific concerns - 365 Oxygen Whitener being an excellent example.
Peroxide - hydrogen peroxide liquids, some with added cleaners and fragrances, but never enzymes
Sudsy Oxi - these are the solids that have oxygen bleaches and detergent, but minimal other ingredients - Oxi Clean Versatile is the longstanding grand dame in this space
Sudsy Oxi Plus - these are solid forms with Sudsy Oxi And Then Some - usually purporting enhanced benefits over Sudsy Oxi alone. - OxiClean White Revive products often fall into this category, as does Clorox 2 powder and pacs - they do not have a complete enzyme package but may have one or two.
Oxi Plus Enzymes - these are the products that combine an oxi with one or more enymes but are not sudsy. Febu is the most complete example.
Other - a catchall for that which doesn’t fit into any particular category well, but brings something to the party.
Truly the long answer is a topic for a different post. But the short answer is that I really like to make sure every load of normal laundry has some oxidizer, some lipase and some DNase. If the load is darker than "medium navy", I want no optical brightener. If the load is white or pastel, I want lots of optical brightener. If it's in the middle I don't care about the optical brightener. If something is egregiously funky and I don't feel like I'm getting flawless odor removal with my usual suspects, I might look first towards the zinc salts to neutralize them, because I tend towards a low-scent laundry chemistry mix. For loads I'm washing with powders, I generally just add Gear Guard liquid. For loads I'm washing with liquids, I tend towards Febu or Biz or the Kirkland Signature Oxi powders, and if it's the Biz or KS (and that's largely driven by how I feel about optical brightener for that load), I'll throw in some Gear Guard or Gear Guard Advanced depending on whether my detergent has lipase today. If I'm washing animal fibers, they never get oxidizer for routine care, and whether I go Gear Guard or Gear Guard Advanced depends on whether my detergent has lipase or not. If I'm dealing with something truly heinous, I do tend to use a very warm to hot wash and use something with TAED, either in the detergent or with the booster - currently that's coming from Vanish Crystal White if it's not in the detergent I'm using in that load.
I take suggestions on Reddit and by email, I regularly survey what's on the shelves at retailers across the US and Canada and I keep an eye out for marketing messages from the usual suspects in laundry chemistry. What I don't do is take money or other consideration for inclusion. My financial disclosure policy is published - if you're new to the site, you may be surprised to find there's not even affiliate links to buy any of this.
Basically a product has to have a reasonable suspicion of being effective at some multiple of the label dose, be marketed primarily for textile care and provide two congruent sources of ingredient information - product packaging, manufacturer websites, Safety Data Sheets, SmartLabel or government registry.